By Adam Smith
Science and communications officer, ANH-Intl
Ever been confused over coffee? Is it bad for you, to be avoided at all costs? Or is it a health drink, packed with antioxidants, that can reduce the risk of chronic disease?
Writing this article, I am comforted by the large take-out cup of steaming, strong, unsweetened black coffee lurking just north of my keyboard. After all, according to a new book, “Coffee is high in antioxidants and there’s hardly any evidence that it’s harmful”. Yippee! That’s what I like to hear. An extra shot in my next vente Americano please, barista!
But hang on. The same author looks like he’s got a downer on locally produced food and drinking plenty of water, so maybe he’s not the best source of information. What about this book instead? “Coffee is highly addictive, offers no nutritional value, and has not been proven safe...women should avoid coffee...discover how eliminating coffee from your diet can not only improve your life, but quite possibly save it.” Oh dear. Hold that extra shot for a minute, will you? Actually, because both of those books are by the same author, she could well be making a career out of bashing coffee. Before I end up completely confused and losing my temper like Ziltoid the Omniscient, I’d better check what the health bods are saying.
Ziltoid with his ever-present cup of coffee. And a bad temper.
Let’s start with the mainstream view. The National Health Service (NHS) in the UK sits on the fence, telling me I should limit caffeine during pregnancy (tricky), but otherwise giving coffee the green light in moderation. Also picking splinters out of its backside is the American Heart Association, while the American Pregnancy Association’s advice mirrors that of the NHS.
What about the natural healthcare side? A member of our team had a discussion on this subject a few years back with one of the leading proponents of green coffee enemas for liver detoxification, particularly among cancer patients. His view was straight forward and to the point : “Coffee’s great – but for goodness sake don’t either roast it or drink it!”.
But, while it’s still easy to find examples of the ‘no coffee is best’ attitude among natural and integrative medicine practitioners, other prominent thinkers in the field are moving in the opposite direction.
Delicious or deadly?
The reason for the confusion is clear: there has been something of a flurry of recent scientific publications touting the health benefits of coffee. We’ve summarised some of the most interesting research in Table 1 below – yes, it’s a coffee table (groan) – to help you decide whether coffee is the thing for you.
The above list is not meant to be comprehensive, but it does provide a decent snapshot of emerging high-quality scientific evidence pointing to coffee’s – and caffeine’s – health benefits. This is not to say, of course, that coffee is without its downsides, as a recent review points out. Logically, the bewildering variety of physiological responses to coffee can be attributed to its complex chemical makeup. Coffee includes, in addition to caffeine, polyphenols such as chlorogenic acid and caffeic acid, diterpenes such as kahweol and cafestol, amino acids, carbohydrates, potassium and other minerals, among many more. Despite all the research that has been performed so far on coffee’s chemistry and health benefits, there is clearly much left to learn.
As with virtually everything in life, the individual response to coffee and/or caffeine can vary tremendously: some people can drink gallons of the stuff without any noticeable ill effects, while others are left jittery, shaking and sleepless after a single cup. Much of this may be due to genetic defects, or single-nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs, pronounced ‘snips’), in the CYP1A2 gene within the liver’s all-important Phase 1 (cytochrome P450 enzyme) detoxification system.
As a coffee lover myself, and one who never touches instant coffee, I find that negative effects build up over time if I drink it every day: these include irritability, itchy eyes, cracked cuticles, dry skin, localised skin rash, grogginess in the morning and difficulty concentrating. The magnitude of the effects clearly changes according to the time of day when I drink coffee, and if I take it with a meal. And if I drink coffee for too many days in a row, stopping suddenly leads to withdrawal symptoms: headache, mood swings and muscle fatigue the most prominent.
So if you love your coffee and don’t want to give it up completely – and with good evidence of its health benefits, why should you? – here’s some tips to help you enjoy your favourite drink while minimising any problems.
But ultimately, the take-home message is this: Something that delivers health benefits will, for some people and at some dosage range, have a detrimental effect. This is what our executive and scientific director, Rob Verkerk PhD, called, in a paper he published in the journal Toxicology, the ‘paradox of overlapping risks and benefits’. He makes the key point that if regulators were to ban all natural substances that pose a health risk to even a nominal sector of the population, the vast majority would no longer be able to experience the benefits associated with those products. Hear that, coffee and alcohol drinkers, and herbal and food supplement users? In other words, the whole principle of using a risk-only based model for regulation, as practiced in the EU, is deeply irrational and flawed if the intention is to create healthy populations.
Updated: 8 Aug 2012
For our FREE Newsletter.